Correcting More Misinformation on Healthcare

As Always, this is great.

Hey folks,

Special Sunday From The Emails. This one again from BG. This is great as always. It's by The Foundry - Paul Krugman’s Health Care Fantasies Posted July 31st, 2009 at 1.25pm in Health Care. Paul Krugman has a Blog over at the NYT.

Paul Krugman just can’t stop spreading misinformation about Medicare and health insurance. Today he writes:

"In the individual insurance market, where people buy insurance directly rather than getting it through their employers, so much money goes into underwriting and other expenses that only around 70 cents of each premium dollar actually goes to care."

This is just plain deceptive. The latest government figures available, 2007 (see Table 12), show that 87.8 cents of every private health insurance premium dollar went to personal health care bills. And that remaining 12.2 cents? In addition to underwriting, administration, advertising, and (gasp!) profit, that 12.2 figure also includes some patient care that insurance companies provided themselves, like disease management and on-call toll-free nurse consultations. Krugman continues:

"Today, Medicare — which is, by the way, one of those “single payer” systems conservatives love to demonize — covers everyone 65 and older. And surveys show that Medicare recipients are much more satisfied with their coverage than Americans with private insurance. Still, most Americans under 65 do have some form of private insurance."

But what Krugman fails to tell readers, or perhaps doesn’t even know, is that many Americans OVER 65 also have some form of private insurance. In other words, Medicare is not quite the “single payer” paragon that Krugman holds it out to be. The latest government figures available, 2005 show that Medicare pays only 51% of Medicare beneficiaries’ health care costs. The rest is made up by the beneficiaries themselves and … those evil health insurance companies.

Krugman is in touch with one key reality: the federal government does play a huge role in our current health care system, controlling more of the spending in the health sector than in any other area of our economy. And that role has been accelerating rapidly. If our health care system is in such bad shape now with so much government control, then why on Earth does Krugman believe even more government control is the answer?

Because he is TOLD to believe it, and more importantly, he is TOLD to report it that way. But of course, don't let the truth stand in your way of attempting to pass Obama's agenda.
Peter

Sources:
The Foundry - Paul Krugman’s Health Care Fantasies


Note: From The Emails is a weekly Segment every Friday, or occasionally anytime, that appears here at the OPNTalk Blog. Please feel free to Email any Articles, Comments, Thoughts, Whatever, that you may like to share to opntalk@gmail.com As always, you never know what you may see here.